The 10-foot lighted polar bear you got at Home Depot this year went up in your yard right away – but you barely had it anchored before somebody from your homeowners association (HOA) said that it’s too big and too early. They say they’re going to fine you. You’ve already seen other displays around the neighborhood, so you’re wondering what rule you broke and whether you’ll have to pay.
Can your HOA really be a grinch? Maybe. An HOA can potentially fine you for a holiday decoration violation if its governing documents give it that authority. However, Texas law may also give you a chance to fix the violation first.
Check the wording of the holiday decoration rule
Get your Declaration of Covenants, Conditions and Restrictions (known as a CC&R) out and look for restrictions on holiday decor. Are dates specified for putting up and taking down decorations? Are there restrictions on size, number and placement of items?
The wording is important. A rule that says lighted decorations can’t be turned on before December 1 is different than a rule about when they can be installed.
If you’re told that the rule changed since last year, ask for a copy of the current version and when it took effect. You can also check the HOA’s enforcement policy and what fine applies to the alleged violation.
Can you fix the violation before the HOA fines you?
For residential associations covered by Chapter 209 of the Texas Property Code, which includes most single-family residential subdivisions where membership is mandatory, the HOA must generally send you written notice by certified mail before imposing a fine. The notice must describe the violation and the dollar amount of the fine.
If the problem can be fixed and poses no threat to public health or safety, the association must typically give you a reasonable amount of time to correct the issue, without a fine. If you put up your yard decor before the permitted date, for example, you may be able to take it down and put it back up when the rules allow. However, prior notice of the same violation within the preceding six months can affect your right to another opportunity to correct it.
If you believe the association misread the rule, is abusing its authority or is selectively enforcing it, you may be entitled to a hearing. A Texas real estate attorney can review the governing documents and the notices you received and help you assert your rights.
